At Catalyst, we are disciples who make disciples. We believe in the power of fellowship, the call to follow Jesus, and the joy of being a community of Kingdom workers. Our desire is for everyone, regardless of background or story, to experience the life-changing love of Jesus.
We are committed to making a difference by living out our faith in the places we live, work, and play. God has uniquely gifted each person, and we want to help you discover and use those gifts for His glory.
We are committed to the Word and Spirit, building our lives on the truth of Scripture and depending on the presence and power of the Holy Spirit to guide, empower, and transform us.
We are committed to authenticity. We don’t expect anyone to have it all together. We believe in creating a space where you can be real, grow in grace and truth, and take the next step in your journey with Jesus.
Through Catalyst Communities, social gatherings, and service opportunities, you’ll find ways to connect, grow, and make a meaningful impact. You’re not just invited to attend—you’re invited to belong.
God has given each of us unique gifts to use for His glory. At Catalyst, we strive to share His love in our everyday lives. Through Catalyst Communities, social events, and serving opportunities, you’ll find ways to grow in faith, connect with others, and impact God’s Kingdom.
In 2025, we have seen God faithfully at work in and through our church as we lived out our mission together. Our 2025 Impact Report highlights the ways lives were impacted through worship gatherings, people taking next steps in their faith, and children and students growing in community, as well as how our church served both locally and globally.
Inside the report, you’ll find stories, key moments, and meaningful numbers that reflect how generosity and obedience fueled ministry throughout the year. Every statistic represents a person, and every story points back to God’s faithfulness. We invite you to explore the 2025 Impact Report and celebrate all that God has done as we continue to look ahead with faith and expectancy.
Our Catalyst Elders assist Pastor Josh & our pastoral team in providing for the needs of the church. In addition to overseeing and guiding the vision/mission, finances, systems, and pastoral health of Catalyst Church, they guide the leadership structure for Catalyst.
Josh Deeter
Pastor Josh enjoys teaching the Bible, leading the church and introducing people to Jesus. Josh has earned a bachelor’s degree in Bible and Religion from Anderson University and has a Master’s of Divinity from Beeson Divinity School at Samford University. He loves his wife Emily, children Judah, Evelyn and JT and his Golden Retriever named Opal.
Paula Spear
Pastor Paula Spear is dedicated to serving the church by utilizing her administration and relational skills. She is a graduate of Anderson University and is ordained in the Church of God (Anderson, IN). Throughout her ministry, Paula has served churches in Indiana, Arizona, Ohio, and Florida. Previously, she worked as a consultant and Children’s Pastor at Catalyst Church. In her free time, Paula enjoys baking and spending time with her family, which includes her husband Kevin, their son Garrett, their daughter Mariah, and their son-in-law Zackary.
Austen Michael
Austen is a Pendleton Heights Alumni who grew up in the Madison county community. He takes an active role in multiple ministries around the area and has a passion for helping to encourage and teach our upcoming generations. Austen focuses these efforts through the teachings of Jesus and strives to help our students grow a personal connection with God that will carry them later in life.
Pastor Alberto Martiez Jordan
Alberto Martínez Jordán is a pastor with over 25 years of ministry experience, serving as a leader and missionary throughout Latin America. Together with his wife, Verónica, they have a blessed family with four children and three grandchildren. His theological training began at a local seminary, continued with a Bachelor of Theological Sciences from Misión Grace University, and a diploma from Anderson University; he is currently pursuing a master’s degree at Anderson University in Indiana. His greatest passion is sharing the Word of God, evangelism, and missions, guided by his love for God and people.
Diana Frank
Diana enjoys creating graphics to effectively communicate information to the people of Catalyst. She’s also been known to find bargains to keep our space looking nice. Diana earned a bachelor’s degree in Marketing and Management from Anderson University. She loves spending time with her friends and her family: husband Chad, children Colton, Hudson, and Arden, and their newfypoo, Murphy.
Heather Webster
Heather graduated from Anderson University with a degree in Elementary Education. She has a deep love for working with children and a passion for nurturing leaders while helping people feel truly connected. Heather and her husband Ryan are proud parents to three children: Braydon, Mallory, and Luke. She is devoted to her family, actively engaged in the community, and enjoys exploring new places through her love of travel.
Izzy Wignall
Izzy is passionate about shepherding singers and musicians while also fostering a culture of creativity and excellence. Izzy earned his bachelor’s degree in Audio Engineering and Commercial Music (double-major) from Greenville College. Izzy’s wife Kellie, their three kids (Luca, Imogen, and Ira) and cat named Miss live in Carmel, Indiana.
Jake Bogard
Jake enjoys teaching the Bible, meeting new people and doing anything active. Jake has earned a bachelor’s degree in Bible and Theology from Moody Bible Institute in Chicago. He loves spending time with his wife Mary, children Levi, Asher, and Leo. You will probably run into him on a sports field or floor near you!
Caroline DeRolf
Caroline is a current Anderson University student with a heart for ministry and a passion for serving. Currently pursuing a degree in Computer and Data Science, Caroline is eager to grow both academically and spiritually while servine behind the scenes at Catalyst.
Kaitlynn Michael
Kaitlynn is passionate about learning and applying her knowledge to improve the lives of others. She is currently a pharmacy intern at CVS while pursuing her Doctor of Pharmacy degree at Butler University, following the completion of her bachelor’s degree at Purdue University. Outside of her academic and professional pursuits, she values meaningful connections and enjoys spending time with her husband, Austen, and caring for their animals.
Noelle Boone
Noelle is a 2nd grade teacher at Lapel Elementary School. She enjoys teaching children and having the opportunity to work with the amazing kids at Catalyst Church. Noelle earned a bachelor’s degree in elementary education and a minor in special education at Anderson University.
Keenan Trimble
Keenan loves intentional discipleship with young people, leading worship, and participating in international missions. He is currently an online theology and leadership student at Life Pacific University and is excited to use his studies and experience practically as he serves and grows with Catalyst.
Email Us
Pastor Alberto Martiez Jordan
Alberto Martínez Jordán es pastor con más de 25 años de ministerio, sirviendo como líder y misionero en toda Latinoamérica. Junto a su esposa, Verónica, han formado una familia bendecida con cuatro hijos y tres nietos. Su preparación teológica comenzó en un seminario local, continuó con un Bachiller en Ciencias Teológicas en la Universidad Misión Grace, y un diplomado en la Universidad de Anderson; actualmente cursa una maestría en la Universidad de Anderson, Indiana. Su mayor pasión es compartir la Palabra de Dios, la evangelización y las misiones, guiado por el amor a Dios y a las personas.
Elisa Mendiola
Elisa is an Anderson University alumni who studied Bible and Religion, and English Education. She currently is an English teacher at Anderson Preparatory Academy and enjoys reading in her free time. Elisa is passionate about guiding Catalyst as they walk their faith journeys, and to be a compassionate leader to those students.
Michelle Kalasa
Michelle is passionate about discipleship, helping others grow in their faith, and enjoys teaching the Bible. Michelle holds a Bachelor’s in Environmental Engineering from Zhejiang University of Technology and a Master of Divinity from Anderson University. Michelle is close to her family and loves them deeply.
Easter at Catalyst
We have services available Thursday, Friday, and Sunday of Holy Week. Click the button below to learn more
Mosaic Ministry (Special Needs Support)
Mosaic Ministry exists to create an inclusive environment where every child can learn about the love of Christ. Our Catalyst Kids Team Members provide individualized support to meet a variety of physical, emotional, and developmental needs—ensuring each child feels safe, valued, and included. Whether that means one-on-one support in a classroom, sensory-friendly tools, or a quiet space when needed, we partner with families to help every child thrive.
3rd – 6th Grade
We provide tailored programming for all grades, designed to meet their spiritual and social needs at each stage.
Kindergarten – 2nd Grade
Our K–2 kids dive into engaging Bible lessons through storytelling, games, music, and crafts that help build a solid foundation of faith. This age group enjoys a fun, high-energy environment where they can explore God’s Word and grow in friendship with others.
Preschool (Potty Trained & Preschool Age)
In our preschool room, children enjoy a fun and engaging time with Bible stories, crafts, music, and interactive play. This space is perfect for kids who are potty trained and ready for a little more structure as they begin to grow in their faith and friendships.
Toddler (Walking to Potty Trained, up to Age 3)
Busy toddlers will feel right at home in this safe, playful environment designed for little ones who are confidently walking but not yet potty trained and under age 3. Our Catalyst Kids Team Members engage them with simple songs, Bible-based lessons, crafts, age-appropriate toys, and plenty of loving attention. Once children are both potty trained and 3 years old, they’ll transition to our Preschool Room.
Interested in Serving?
Let us help connect you to the opportunities available at Catalyst to live out your purpose and serve others. Learn more about our serving teams below.
Catalyst Kids (Infant-6th Grade)
The Catalyst Kids ministry is a wonderful place to get connected and make a difference in a child’s life. If you love to cuddle with babies, “sing” along with preschoolers, or lead a small group of elementary schoolers…we have a place for you.
Student Ministries (7th-12th Grade)
Our very active Youth Student ministry is always looking for leaders with positions ranging from hospitality coordinators, game masters, group leaders and more. Pouring into our kids in 7th grade and higher is a rewarding and fun experience.
Events
The events team works to bring Catalyst to the community and the community to Catalyst. There are plenty of service opportunities for anyone who loves to plan church-wide events or events that bless the Pendleton & Madison County community.
Hospitality
Our Hospitality team is tagged with the amazing opportunity to welcome members and guests into our Catalyst home each and every week. This team consists of individuals who help greet on Sundays as well as the Connections team that works during the week to follow up with guests from the Sunday before.
Worship
From playing an instrument to serving on audio/visual and logistics teams, the worship band & worship arts team is an amazing opportunity to use your talents to praise and glorify God, while blessing the church as you lead them to the same place of praise.
Marketing
The marketing team provides strategic oversight for church-wide marketing and communications as well as oversees the marketing and communication of the church’s brand and message through various media and events.
How Can We Pray For You?
